Ukraine’s Refugee Crisis Is Unprecedented. The Response Must Be, Too.
In the weeks since Russia invaded Ukraine, almost three million of the country’s 44 million residents have left the country.
The rate of the Ukrainian exodus is unprecedented in recent history. Europe’s response to the crisis has been similarly remarkable — both in its immediate generosity as well as in contrast to how poorly many European countries have treated refugees from Africa and the Middle East.
The rate at which Ukrainians are fleeing is unprecedented
Comparing 18 days of refugees from Ukraine with
countries’ largest one-year increases in refugees.
Venezuela
2017–2018
Ukraine
Feb. 24–March 13
+2,820,000
refugees
+2,920,000
Each dot represents
1,000 people
Afghanistan
1980–1981
Rwanda
1993–1994
+2,145,000
+1,807,000
Syria
2012–2013
Iraq
2005–2006
+1,754,000
+1,201,000
The rate at which Ukrainians are fleeing is unprecedented
Comparing 18 days of refugees from Ukraine with countries’ largest one-year increases in refugees.
Venezuela
2017–2018
Ukraine
Feb. 24–March 13
Afghanistan
1980–1981
Rwanda
1993–1994
+2,820,000
refugees
+2,920,000
+2,145,000
+1,807,000
Each dot represents
1,000 people
Syria
2012–2013
Iraq
2005–2006
South Sudan
2016–2017
Ethiopia
1979–1980
Liberia
1989–1990
+1,754,000
+1,201,000
+1,003,000
+944,000
+735,000
The rate at which Ukrainians are fleeing is unprecedented
Comparing 18 days of refugees from Ukraine with countries’ largest one-year increases in refugees.
Venezuela
2017–2018
Ukraine
Feb. 24–March 13
Afghanistan
1980–1981
Rwanda
1993–1994
Each dot represents
1,000 people
+2,820,000
refugees
+2,920,000
+2,145,000
+1,807,000
Syria
2012–2013
Iraq
2005–2006
South Sudan
2016–2017
Ethiopia
1979–1980
Liberia
1989–1990
+735,000
+1,003,000
+944,000
+1,754,000
+1,201,000
But the coming months are likely to be the real test of the West’s commitment to Ukraine. As Russian attacks increase in western Ukraine, experts estimate that the number of refugees could double. Leaders in Europe and the United States will need to start thinking about long-term resettlement efforts for the war’s victims.
Early refugees from Ukraine often had relatives outside the country and the means to reach them. That’s less likely to be true for people who decide to leave in the coming weeks, said Steve Gordon, a security adviser for the aid group Mercy Corps. “The next wave of refugees will need much more assistance,” he added.
The sudden arrival of millions of people who need housing, education and health care will challenge public services in European countries. So far, that challenge has fallen largely upon Ukraine’s neighbors to the west — Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania and Moldova — which are some of the poorest countries in Europe.
Moldova, for example, has one of Europe’s lowest gross domestic products per capita and a population of just over three million. The influx of tens of thousands of Ukrainians has put the country in “a very, very tight spot,” according to the country’s foreign minister.
Refugees from all countries, 2021
Russia
Belarus
16,143
Poland
3,060
7,103
Each dot represents
1,000 people
Slovakia
1,065
Ukraine
Moldova
447
Romania
Hungary
5,499
5,747
Crimea
Refugees from Ukraine, since Feb. 24
Russia
131,365
Belarus
Poland
1,226
1,720,227
Slovakia
Moldova
204,862
Ukraine
106,994
Romania
84,671
Hungary
Crimea
255,291
Refugees from all countries, 2021
Russia
16,143
Belarus
3,060
Poland
7,103
Each dot represents
1,000 people
Slovakia
Ukraine
1,065
Hungary
Moldova
5,747
447
Romania
5,499
Crimea
Refugees from Ukraine, since Feb. 24
Russia
131,365
Belarus
Poland
1,226
1,720,227
Slovakia
Ukraine
204,862
Romania
84,671
Moldova
106,994
Hungary
Crimea
255,291
Refugees from all countries, 2021
Refugees from Ukraine, since Feb. 24
Russia
Russia
131,365
16,143
Belarus
Poland
Belarus
3,060
Poland
1,226
1,720,227
7,103
Each dot represents
1,000 people
Slovakia
Slovakia
204,862
1,065
Ukraine
Ukraine
Hungary
Moldova
5,747
447
Romania
Romania
84,671
5,499
Moldova
Hungary
106,994
Crimea
Crimea
255,291
If countries struggle to integrate Ukrainian refugees, goodwill could turn into apathy or even hostility. “We know that hospitality can wear out,” said Kathryn Mahoney, a spokesperson for the United Nations refugee agency.
The Syrian refugee crisis shows how quickly public sympathy can wane. In 2015, newspapers published a photo of Alan Kurdi, a 2-year-old Syrian boy who drowned while his family was trying to cross the Mediterranean Sea to escape the country’s civil war. Widespread outrage led to a hundredfold increase the following week in the number of donations to a Red Cross fund for Syria.
Within two months, however, donations had dropped back down to a trickle. Even when people are confronted with powerful, graphic images, their attention dissipates after a few weeks, said Paul Slovic, a psychology professor at the University of Oregon who has studied the “psychic numbing” that can occur after tragedies.
Sympathy for refugees can be fleeting
Donations to a Swedish Red Cross fund for Syrian
refugees, before and after newspapers published photos
of Alan Kurdi.
Photos published
10,000
donations
5,000
0
Sept. 2015
Oct.
Nov.
Sympathy for refugees can be fleeting
Donations to a Swedish Red Cross fund for Syrian refugees, before and after newspapers published photos of Alan Kurdi.
Photos published
10,000 donations
5,000
0
Sept. 2015
Oct.
Nov.
As sympathy for refugees fades, spite can fill the void.
Around 2015, Denmark took in more than 30,000 refugees from Syria. Recently, however, Danish authorities have revoked some of those people’s residency permits, despite reports that refugees who return to Syria have faced torture and sexual violence. Stripped of their right to live in Denmark, some of the country’s Syrian refugees have been detained for months in deportation centers, with no indication of when they will be permitted to leave.
Before psychic numbing sets in and the days of Russia’s invasion begin to blur together, world leaders must put comprehensive, durable protections in place for Ukrainian refugees.
The European Union is off to a good start. In a unanimous vote, the E.U. agreed to let most Ukrainians live, work and study across the bloc for up to three years.
Work should now begin on a plan to equitably resettle refugees across E.U. member states. Poland has already absorbed an incredible number of people; countries like Germany, France and Spain should be prepared to help millions more find homes, schools and health care. Every country must open its arms to Ukrainians and non-Ukrainians who were living in the country — some of whom have faced discrimination at the border.
“Hosting refugees is a global public good,” said David Miliband, the head of the International Rescue Committee. “We need to share the responsibility.”
In the United States, President Biden has already granted Ukrainians the ability to remain and work in the country for 18 months. Those protections, however, apply only to Ukrainians who were already in the United States.
If the Biden administration is willing to arm Ukrainian fighters — whose victories benefit the United States by diminishing Russia’s real and perceived power — then it must also share responsibility for the Ukrainians whose homes are being shelled.
That will be difficult, but not impossible. Year after year, the Trump administration slashed the number of refugees that were allowed into the United States, forcing resettlement agencies to lay off employees and close offices.
To restaff those programs, Congress should pass the GRACE Act, which sets a minimum for the number of refugees that the United States takes in each year. That would help reassure potential hires that their jobs won’t disappear after the next presidential election.
In addition to bolstering the country’s refugee programs, President Biden should allow people fleeing Ukraine to live in the United States without a visa. So should Britain, which has issued a paltry 4,000 visas to Ukrainians as of Monday.
Ukrainians will likely need assistance for many years to come. History has shown that refugee situations almost inevitably last longer than they’re expected to.
Many refugees remain displaced for years
Countries with more than a million refugees for at least five years since 1975.
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
6 mil. refugees
Syria
4 mil.
2 mil.
0
2 mil.
South Sudan
0
2 mil.
Somalia
0
2 mil.
Iraq
0
6 mil.
Afghanistan
4 mil.
2 mil.
0
Ethiopia
2 mil.
0
Many refugees remain displaced for years
Countries with more than a million refugees for at least five years since 1975.
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
6 mil. refugees
Syria
4 mil.
2 mil.
0
2 mil.
South Sudan
0
2 mil.
Somalia
0
2 mil.
Iraq
0
6 mil.
Afghanistan
4 mil.
2 mil.
0
Ethiopia
2 mil.
0
If Russia’s war turns into a yearslong occupation, millions of Ukrainians could end up like Syria’s refugees, stranded in a legal, economic and emotional limbo. People who have already lost their homes and livelihoods will be robbed of their futures as well.
It doesn’t have to be that way. Almost every country has expressed solidarity with Ukraine. The outpouring of compassion is an opportunity to reset the way that refugees are treated, in Ukraine and around the world.