What do you think?
Rate this book
384 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2012
For the Netsilik, this island is rich in resources for food, clothing, shelter, and tool-making. […] The reason Franklin’s men could not survive is that humans don’t adapt to novel environments the way other animals do or by using our individual intelligence. None of the 105 big brains figured out how to use driftwood, which was available on King William Island’s west coast where they camped, to make the reserve composite bows, which the Inuit used when stalking caribou. They further lacked the vast body of cultural know-how about building snow houses, creating fresh water, hunting seals, making kayaks, spearing salmon and tailoring cold-weather clothing (23 -4).Bown's account of Amundsen's life supports Henrich's analysis. Amundsen had daring and bravado, but he mostly comes across as a pragmatic planner rather than a romantic hero. Oddly, in spite of his successes, and in spite of his dramatic death, I suspect readers prefer the romantic pride (arrogance?) and tragic suffering we see in the adventures of the British explorers.