Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
OK
God's Architect: Pugin and the Building of Romantic Britain by Hill, Rosemary [07 August 2008] Paperback – August 7, 2008
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherPenguin Books Ltd
- Publication dateAugust 7, 2008
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now
Product details
- ASIN : B00C7GCFYE
- Publisher : Penguin Books Ltd (August 7, 2008)
- Language : English
- Item Weight : 0.01 ounces
- Best Sellers Rank: #12,178,088 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- Customer Reviews:
About the author
Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read author blogs and more
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon-
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
I especially appreciated three aspects of her work.
First is her treatment of the surrounding cultural, political, and religious issues that surrounded Pugin's career and the Gothic revival. Getting a better grasp of the Picturesque, the Oxford Movement, and the spirit of the Young Victorians is so helpful.
Second is her sympathetic but judicious approach. She is able to understand and describe thought patterns and practices that would seem odd to most today without criticizing or condescending. At the same time, she is able to offer many judgments of history (about his unfair treatment, his own inconsistencies, etc.) that are both refreshing and satisfying.
Finally, she has an understanding not just of the history, but of the architecture. As an architect myself, I found her judgments well-informed, helpful, and astute. She's able to grasp the significance and points of interest in his various works and guide the reader through his development (including his many frustrations). I found myself reading many portions with my phone nearby to look up additional pictures of the projects mentioned, but even without that extra effort, Hill does a fine job conveying the architecture in words.
As an architect, an anglophile, an evangelical, and a lover of Gothic, I will find it very difficult to top this book.
God's Architect (Yale UP, 2009) is a monumental work of scholarship, but because it lacks a unifying thesis or central point, Rosemary Hill's sprawling 600-page, fifteen-years-in-the-making biography of the nineteenth century English architect Augustus Pugin (1812-1852) is, in the final analysis, unfortunately, a failure. The closest thing to a central thesis that she offers, the closest thing to an explanation of Pugin's extraordinary life and career, is her speculation that he contracted syphilis, possibly before he was out of his teens, and that it was that disease that underlay many of his physical and mental problems and that led finally to his insanity and death, at the age of forty.
Hill had the sense not to marry her biography to syphilis; at best, or at worst, God's Architecture only flirts with it. She does not mention syphilis until page 151, and not again until page 257, but she returns to the subject near the end, on page 492 and again on page 598, in the Epilogue, when she has no other explanation for Pugin's extraordinary life and work to fall back on.
If there is no point to Hill's biography, there was, quite literally, to Pugin's life and career. He was a practitioner and champion of what he preferred to call Pointed architecture. One of his most important books was The True Principles of Pointed or Christian Architecture (1841). He said he converted to Catholicism as a result of his study of Pointed architecture. Hill's failure to take into account and adequately explain Pugin's lifelong commitment to and obsession with Pointed architecture is the Achilles' heel of God's Architect.
In making light of the titles and honors he never was awarded, in spite of his important contributions in architecture and the applied arts, Pugin once quipped that the only letters he was ever likely to have after his name were V.P., which he made clear stood for "very pointed." But Hill did not explain his "very pointed" quip, either in her biography or when she was asked directly about it in an interview with The Guardian.
Hill is good at showing Pugin's contributions to architecture and the applied arts, and conversely in showing how egotistical and obtuse he could be, but not why he was so crazy about Pointed architecture. Pugin believed Pointed architecture had been the means to his salvation by pointing , literally and figuratively, toward heaven and Catholicism. Syphilis may or may not have killed Pugin, but Pointed architecture is what he lived for.
Top reviews from other countries
I am not sure that it was possible to divide his private life from his public interest as architect, designer and polemicist. The fact that as a Catholic convert he so strongly believed that medaeval Gothic represented the highroad to a true Catholic architecture, ascribing as Pagan anything diriving from Vitruvius, effectively meant that his personal convictions drove his architectural standpoint. At all events this author does not attempt to separate into different chapters his leisure interests and love life from his professional practice and so, every so often, we have to be prepared to be jerked on the same page from somewhat highbrow matters into sentimental affairs of the heart !
There is so much ground covered in this densely written, well researched work. Who would imagine, for instance, that while designing interior details for the Palace of Westminster for Sir Charles Barry, our hero is concerned with salvaging 18 tons of Russian tallow with a purpose-bought longboat called Caroline ? Although now best known for this collaboration with Barry when he got little money and even less credit at the time, Pugin had several aristocratic patrons, the most important being the Catholic Lord Shrewsbury. Pugin had a favorite builder in George Myers, and was loyal to a number of suppliers : John Hardman for metalwork and latterly stained glass; Herbert Minton for ceramics, especially encaustic tiles; J Gregory Crace for textiles and wallpapers.
A great many pages are devoted to ecclesiastical matters that were of profound ground-shattering significance at the time but which now in this relatively agnostic age seem of little relevance ! Pugin as a Catholic convert was always friendly towards the movers and shakers of the Anglican High Church Movements hoping that ultimately a reconcialition with Rome would be found. So we hear much about the Tractarians, and Puseyites that animated the Oxford movement, and the Camden Society, originally formed to study Church architecture, which originated in Cambridge.
Pugin expounded his appreciation of pointed medaeval architecture in "Contrasts" where he compared it favorably to the increasingly debased Pagan works that had come back into favour since the Renaissance. Later came "True Principles" which opened up the possibilities for architects to tamper with Gothic. Gothic could now evolve provided the external and internal appearance of an edifice was illustrative and in accordance with the purpose for which it was designed. I make these points here because these treatises proved to be very influential and helped bring about the Gothic revival of the High Victorian Era with architects like Street, Scott and William Butterfield carrying the flame of pointed architecture onto every High Street in the country.
Pugin died at forty, insane, having married three times and professionally having achieved so much. He could be witty : "Being an architect to one grate or fireplace is worse than keeping a fishstall !" However he often drove others as hard as himself, was sometimes undiplomatic and certainly made some enemies.
All in all Rosemary Hill has written an astonishing biography. It makes for an excellent read in its own right, but it is particularly recommended as background reading for architectural students, students of social history, and indeed seminarians preparing for ordinatiion ! There is a comprehensive compilation of Pugin's executed works at the end of the book.
I can highly recommend this book, and not just to those who are knowledgeable and interested in architecture and design. I certainly didn't think I was interested in the former before I read this book, but reading Pugin's story has quite changed my mind.
On the troubled matter of the Houses of Parliament, she is superb. Whilst the whole truth will never be known, it's absolutely clear that Barry saw Pugin as a highly valued (although poorly rewarded) sub-contractor. As Hill makes clear, there was probably no one else on the planet who could have produced the designs as quickly and as perfectly as he, but his erratic health and behaviour as well as his ability to make enemies mean that his could only ever be a supporting role. It's a complex picture but the building we see now is truly Barry and Pugin's work not one or the other.
Hill has done a superb job in collating her facts and is not frightened to say what we simply cannot know due to the passage of time and lack of information. Overall this is a great read and will leave you wanting to see more of his work.